When it comes to ensuring safety in the bathroom, having the right equipment makes all the difference.
Two popular options that can significantly reduce the risk of falls in the shower and make bathing more comfortable are shower chairs and tub benches.
You may think these two terms are interchangeable, but there are pretty big differences between them.
Long-story-short: shower chairs fit entirely in your tub, while tub benches extend over the tub wall, allowing you to sit on it before entering.
If you’re interested in the longer story, keep reading.
In this article, we’ll go over all the differences between shower chairs and tub benches, highlighting their pros and cons to help you decide which option best suits your needs.
After reading, you’ll know which piece of equipment is the better fit for your bathroom.
| Shower Chairs | Tub Benches | |
| Fit | Completely inside shower/tub | Two feet inside tub, two feet outside |
| Size | Smaller | Larger |
| Good For | Walk-in showers Small bathrooms Seniors with more mobility | Tubs Larger bathrooms Seniors with less mobility |
| Cost | ~$30 – $50 | ~$60 – $80 |
What’s A Shower Chair?
A shower chair is a sturdy, waterproof chair designed to be placed directly in the shower.
It typically features a backrest and armrests for added support (although some simpler models don’t have these) and non-slip feet to keep the chair stable on wet surfaces.
Shower chairs are available in a variety of sizes and styles, some of which have additional features like padded seats, adjustable height, and swivel seats for easier access.
Pros of a Shower Chair
- Full Support: With the option to get back and armrests, a shower chair offers full support while you bathe, making it ideal for individuals with balance issues or limited strength.
- Stability: The non-slip feet ensure the chair remains stable, even on wet surfaces, providing added safety.
- Comfort: The backrest and armrests allow for a more comfortable bathing experience, especially if you need to sit for an extended period.
- Portability: Many shower chairs are lightweight and easy to move, making them convenient for use in different bathrooms or to take along when traveling.
- Size: Shower chairs are smaller, allowing them to fit in small bathrooms.
- Cost: Shower chairs vary in cost, depending on brand and features, but most are affordable (~$30 – $50).
Cons of a Shower Chair
- Accessibility: If you put a shower chair in a tub, you have to be able to step over the tub to access the seat.
What’s a Tub Bench?
A tub bench, also known as a transfer bench, is a long seat that straddles the side of the bathtub, allowing part of the bench to be inside the tub and part outside.
This design makes it easier to transfer in and out of the bathtub because you can sit on the bench outside of the tub and slide in – you don’t have to step over the tub wall.
This makes a tub bench an attractive option for seniors who have difficulty stepping over the tub’s high edge.
Tub benches typically have non-slip feet, a backrest, and sometimes armrests for added support.
And if your mobility is more compromised, you can even find tub benches with sliding seats that make it even easier to get into the tub.
Pros of a Tub Bench
- Ease of Transfer: A tub bench allows you to sit down outside the tub and then slide over into the tub, making it easier and safer to get in and out without lifting your legs over the tub’s edge.
- Versatility: Tub benches are versatile and can be used both for showering and bathing, depending on your preference.
- Support: Like shower chairs, tub benches often come with backrests and armrests for added support and comfort during use.
- Safety: The design of a tub bench minimizes the risk of slipping when entering or exiting the bathtub, a common area where accidents occur.
Cons of a Tub Bench
- Space Requirements: Tub benches are larger than shower chairs and require more space in the bathroom. They can also make the tub less accessible for others who do not need the bench.
- Cost: Tub benches are great if you have the room for one, but they usually cost a little more than a shower chair. Prices will vary, but expect to pay $60 – $80 for most options.
Which Is Right for You?
Choosing between a shower chair and a tub bench depends on your specific needs, bathroom setup, and personal preferences.
Here are some factors to consider:
- Mobility and Strength: If you have difficulty lifting your legs over the edge of the tub, a tub bench may be the better choice as it allows for easier and safer transfers. If you don’t mind stepping over the tub and simply need a seat once in, a shower chair might make more sense.
- Bathroom Space: Consider the size of your bathroom and shower area. A shower chair is ideal for smaller showers, while a tub bench requires more space and is better suited for larger bathrooms with a bathtub.
- Primary Use: Think about how you primarily bathe. If you usually take showers, a shower chair is a more straightforward option. If you prefer baths or need to transfer into a tub, a tub bench offers more versatility.
- Portability: If you need a portable solution for travel or use in multiple bathrooms, a shower chair might be more convenient. Tub benches, due to their size and design, are generally less portable.
Final Thoughts
Well, I guess that about does it.
These are pretty simple devices, so there isn’t a ton of info to go over here – choosing between them really boils down to what you need and how your bathroom is setup.
If you have a small bathroom and can’t afford to lose any floorspace, you’re likely better off with a shower chair.
If you have enough room and would like to make it easier to get in over a tub, a tub bench may make more sense.
Shower chairs and tub benches both offer valuable support and safety in the bathroom, but the right choice depends on your individual needs and circumstances.
If you’re still unsure which option is best for you, you may want to request a consult with an occupational therapist, who can assess your situation and recommend the most suitable solution.
No matter which you choose, investing in a shower chair or tub bench is a big step towards safer, more comfortable bathing and greater independence in your daily life.
